Participants in CISC’s tree walk stop beneath the loquat tree on 8th street. Photo by Carmen Hom

On 8th Ave there is a loquat tree with tangled branches taut and firm, in front of the historic Eng Family Homestead. It frames the threshold of the one story bungalow and reaches up into the sky, casting full shadows across the structure. 

In one of Seattle’s most urbanized corridors, the tree is an oasis of idyllic nature. When the tree was first planted by the Eng family in 1961, no one knew if it would be able to produce loquat, the small citrus fruit native to China. Surprisingly, it not only thrived and flowered, but has continued to grow ever since. 

The loquat tree is one of many memorable trees in the Chinatown International District neighborhood, and a guaranteed stop on a community tree walk tour led by Karia Wong and organized by the Chinese Information Services Center (CISC). 

On Friday, August 21st, CISC’s second floor meeting room was buzzing with excitement from elders and children alike. Wong was lively and energetic and managed to rally the intergenerational group of participants, hyping them up on the science and history of trees in the neighborhood. 

To get the audience excited, Wong had planned a series of games and activities. The kids squealed with delight as they answered true or false “tree facts” for little prizes. Elders enthusiastically called out their best guesses as well.

After the initial orientation, Wong took the group outside for a guided tour of the trees in the neighborhood. She threw her voice out to reach the sprawling group, shifting her pace to accommodate the varying mobility needs of elders in the group. 

The group stopped by Danny Woo Children’s Park, where Wong pointed out gingko trees, drooping low with fan-shaped leaves. These are one  of the world’s oldest tree species. They turn a pale yellow golden color, and are also found by Hing Hay Park.  

Along Jackson street, Wong pointed out the amur cork tree which is native to northeastern China. Each leaf cluster has an odd number of leaves and at the tail end of summer, the trees were a bright green as they shaded the stretch of street between 6th and 8th Avenue. 

Japanese zelkova is prominent and recognizable in the neighborhood. Their trunks are a patchwork of color as the bark haphazardly peels off. Lastly, there is the honey locust found along 12th and Weller, closer to Little Saigon.

These trees have been in the neighborhood for decades, some of them brought to the area by immigrants. They are rooted into the ground despite their origins from other parts of the world. Their stories parallel the lives of the immigrant communities who have shaped the CID. However, even local residents and regular visitors to the neighborhood may not notice their arboreal companions. 

Jacky comes into the CID neighborhood regularly and has been doing so for years. “I’ve been here for ten years, seriously, today is the first time I was looking at all the trees in the CID,” he said. ”Having more trees makes the environment more beautiful. Because right now you can only see the wall and the concrete.” 

Participants on CISC’s tree walk. Photo by Carmen Hom

Why trees have an impact on health and public safety

Trees are invaluable, although in an urban landscape they are often relegated to sidewalks and parks and not given much thought. But they serve integral needs in any landscape, even in a concrete corridor. Providing shelter, habitat for birds, shade, and helping offset carbon emissions are only part of why trees are crucial.

Between 2016 and 2021, Seattle’s tree canopy cover declined from 28.6% to 28.1%, according to the 2021 Tree Canopy Assessment report produced by the Seattle Office of Sustainability and Environment (OSE), using findings from a team led by the University of Vermont Spatial Analysis Lab. In that time period Seattle lost 255 acres of canopy, a relative decline of 1.7% amounting to an area the size of Green Lake. In disadvantaged areas — census tracts with higher percentages of people of color and lower income — there is 31% less tree canopy than advantaged areas. In response to the loss of canopy, Seattle’s OSE began the Foresting Seattle project. 

After looking at canopy data across the city and correlating data around air quality, health disparities and demographics, OSE decided to concentrate efforts in two neighborhoods: Beacon Hill and the CID, both of which have some of the lowest tree canopy in the city. Not surprisingly, this cascades into and intersects with several environmental justice concerns, such as air quality and heat, which have implications for people’s health.

With the I-5 highway cutting the CID and Little Saigon in half, a lack of trees to absorb this high concentration of carbon leaves residents susceptible to airborne particulate matter, as well as diesel exposure and other air toxics. The Washington Environmental Health Disparities Map ranks the CID at 9 (out of 10) for proximity to heavy roadways and 10 out of 10 for risk from diesel and other air toxics. 

Then consider heat — without the cooling effects of shade cover, the CID becomes a heat island which increases the likelihood of heat exhaustion, stroke and several other illnesses.

In 2021, the city’s Tree Canopy Assessment report found: “There are larger areas of low canopy and warmer temperatures, like the heat islands in and around industrial areas and major transportation corridors. There are also smaller areas where neighborhoods with low canopy experience higher temperatures, such as neighborhoods in the Chinatown International District and in the south end of Rainier Valley.” These patterns are of increasingly urgent significance as average summer temperatures soar in the northwest. 

Residents, however, aren’t always aware of the cost of low tree canopy in the neighborhood. “Most people don’t know about the air quality,” said Wong, who leads the neighborhood tree walk. “They know that it’s hot, but they don’t know if there’s anything that they could do. During hot days, you will see seniors staying downstairs because it’s cooler to stay downstairs outside the building than inside the home because of the heat.”

In cases like these, tree cover fills an important need, providing natural cooling and ventilation where residents can find respite. Trees are also buffers in the ongoing challenge of public safety in the neighborhood. Nate Moxley, Foresting Seattle’s program manager, said one of the main recommendations has been pruning trees to create sightlines. 

“If you have a big bushy tree with low branches, people could conceivably hide. One of the ways that you mitigate that is by cutting back branches,” Moxley said. 

Public safety continues to be a concern in the neighborhood. In an urban landscape, trees not only can be managed to create sightlines and deter loitering or suspicious activity, but the aesthetic benefits of tree lined streets can create a different perception of the neighborhood. In other words, public safety can be approached through environmental design principles. “When you add a tree, that gives a sense of place, a sense of beauty and tranquility that can add to safety,” Moxley said.

Currently the OSE is focused on engaging the neighborhood for residents’ input on where to bring in new trees and what kinds of trees to bring in. While community members might think in terms of aesthetics, considering what areas would look fuller with more shade, there are infrastructure realities that make reforesting an urban environment more challenging.

“Some areas of the neighborhood, in fact, are built up, and so you don’t have access to soil in some places,” explained Moxley. Other times, an empty plot is empty because it is home to underground utility wirings. “There are many hoops to jump through.”

After Wong’s tree walk, the group reassembled in CISC’s second floor meeting room. The conversation was lively throughout the room as children looked at a display explaining the different trees and their characteristics, such as leaf shape. Wong then led an activity, bringing out larger poster boards with Cantonese writing.

 The board had several boxes, each with a prompt, asking people to vote for attributes they’d like to see in the neighborhood and where they would like to see them. The next step was to map out those suggestions on an aerial map of the CID. These recommendations among others will be shared with various city agencies who manage and work with trees such as  the Seattle Department of Transportation, Seattle Parks and Recreation, Seattle City Light and Seattle Public Utilities’ Trees for Neighborhoods program  according to Moxley. 

However, Moxley is careful to point out that recommendations are just an initial step, though they are crucial in a participatory methodology to include community in city decisions. Neighborhood committees will source community recommendations for the Foresting Seattle initiative through community engagement efforts like the current iteration in the CID. The implementation and feasibility of the recommendations themselves will have to be determined by city agencies whose work will intersect with implementation. 

Seniors cast votes for their tree preferences after the tree walk. Photo by Carmen Hom

All of this brings an important question to the forefront – with so much investment in community engagement, how will the city show accountability to the recommendations and process that community members have been invited into?

Moxley said that the OSE team is committed to “report backs,” and plans to circle back to community partners and members to brief them on a quarterly or semi-annual basis with updates on the report. 

The timeline will stretch out into early 2027. 

Wong has been working with immigrant communities for decades, but when she was first brought on to work on the foresting project, she was stumped. “I start thinking, oh, this is such a boring topic. I really need help to make it interesting, but it turns out that actually it was a good project to help people and to advance the environmental equity in the community.”

The more Wong learned, and the more she taught this to her community, she realized that the idea of trees and their symbolism spoke deeply to the immigrant communities. 

Wong explained that most of the loquat trees in the neighborhood come from one particular loquat tree. The tree’s fruit has a unique sweetness, a taste that is distinctly different from the loquats found in Hong Kong or even ones one might find in a market in Vancouver (which shares a similar climate to Seattle). That uniqueness itself feels akin to the immigrant experience; setting down roots and building a life that has a distinct flavor from the past.

“So this is how unique each individual immigrant is,” said Wong. “We fight, we relieve, and we thrive, and the fruit that we have is really unique.”

In that way, the work of thinking about the neighborhood’s trees and overall sense of place reverberates beyond environmental impacts and beautifies a neighborhood that has often dealt with bad press and public safety issues. 

Participants in CISC’s tree walk stop beneath the Loquat tree on 8th street. Photo by Carmen Hom

“There is a saying that the people who came before us plant the tree, the people who come after will enjoy the benefit of the tree,” Wong said. “A lot of immigrants when we move, you know, uprooted from our home country, we are not only hoping for a good life or better life for ourselves. The most important thing is we want our future generation to have a better life.” 

Reimagining a neighborhood abundant with green growth is, in some ways, an extension of the immigrant dream, the one that built the CID in the first place and continues to shape its shifting legacy. Some community members are most excited about the opportunity for cleaner air and improvement in air pollution as well as more opportunities for shade so people can rest in favorite lounging spaces like Hing Hay Park. Others look forward to the aesthetic improvement of the likes of flowering trees and the relaxing nature of being surrounded by greenspace in contrast to concrete walls. 

Get in touch CISC to learn more: https://cisc-seattle.org/get-involved/#volunteer

Editor’s note: This article originally stated that Seattle had lost more than 28% of its canopy cover over the last ten years. In fact, Seattle’s tree canopy saw a relative decline of 1.7% between 2016 to 2021, according to the 2021 Tree Canopy Assessment report produced by the Seattle Office of Sustainability and Environment (OSE), using findings from a team led by the University of Vermont Spatial Analysis Lab. The article has been updated with this correction.

Previous articleBody image to menopause: Singapore-based graphic novelists fearlessly discuss taboo women’s health topics
Next articleCambodian American Community celebrates the first Seattle Mariners Cambodian Heritage Night